American Financial [AFG] vs Progressive [PGR] Detailed Stock Comparison

American Financial Group Inc.

NYSE
Loading...

Progressive Corporation

NYSE
Loading...

TLDR: Quick Comparison Summary

Based on 20 vital metrics comparison: American Financial Group Inc. wins in 6 metrics, Progressive Corporation wins in 14 metrics, with 0 ties. Progressive Corporation appears stronger overall.

View Metrics Details

Vital Metrics Comparison

Metric American Financial Group Inc. Progressive Corporation Better
P/E Ratio (TTM) 12.92 10.45 Progressive Corporation
Price-to-Book Ratio 2.25 3.75 American Financial Group Inc.
Debt-to-Equity Ratio 42.30 26.17 Progressive Corporation
PEG Ratio 0.72 1.06 American Financial Group Inc.
EV/EBITDA 8.70 8.33 Progressive Corporation
Profit Margin (TTM) 10.60% 12.93% Progressive Corporation
Operating Margin (TTM) 21.27% 16.39% American Financial Group Inc.
EBITDA Margin (TTM) 21.27% 16.39% American Financial Group Inc.
Return on Equity 18.14% 37.90% Progressive Corporation
Return on Assets (TTM) 2.34% 7.94% Progressive Corporation
Free Cash Flow (TTM) $1.53B $17.20B Progressive Corporation
Dividend Yield 6.87% 8.67% Progressive Corporation
1-Year Return 4.69% -33.18% American Financial Group Inc.
Price-to-Sales Ratio (TTM) 1.37 1.34 Progressive Corporation
Enterprise Value $11.07B $126.25B Progressive Corporation
EV/Revenue Ratio 1.39 1.41 American Financial Group Inc.
Revenue per Share (TTM) $95 $153 Progressive Corporation
Earnings per Share (Diluted) $10.08 $19.65 Progressive Corporation
Beta (Stock Volatility) 0.67 0.33 Progressive Corporation
Short % of Float 2.22% 1.25% Progressive Corporation

American Financial Group Inc. vs Progressive Corporation Stock Performance Analysis

Loading Price Chart...

AFG
PGR

Performance Comparison

Short-term Returns

Stock1D1W1M3M6MYTD
American Financial Group Inc.0.07%-3.53%-1.93%-2.30%-2.15%-4.39%
Progressive Corporation-1.71%-1.75%-2.90%-9.32%-14.84%-8.80%

Long-term Returns

Stock1Y3Y5Y10Y15Y20Y
American Financial Group Inc.4.69%11.26%-7.48%78.57%274.60%348.67%
Progressive Corporation-33.18%47.03%89.72%479.08%807.96%589.11%

Performance & Financial Health Analysis: American Financial Group Inc. vs Progressive Corporation

MetricAFGPGR
Market Information
Market Cap i$11.01B$120.11B
Market Cap CategoryLarge capLarge cap
10 Day Avg. Volume i468,5943,008,670
90 Day Avg. Volume i534,2183,010,043
Last Close$128.87$193.46
52 Week Range$121.75 - $150.02$189.20 - $289.96
% from 52W High-14.10%-33.28%
All-Time High$152.29 (Apr 18, 2022)$292.99 (Mar 17, 2025)
% from All-Time High-15.38%-33.97%
Growth Metrics
Quarterly Revenue Growth-0.03%0.09%
Quarterly Earnings Growth0.17%0.10%
Financial Health
Profit Margin (TTM) i0.11%0.13%
Operating Margin (TTM) i0.21%0.16%
Return on Equity (TTM) i0.18%0.38%
Debt to Equity (MRQ) i42.3026.17
Cash & Liquidity
Book Value per Share (MRQ)$57.78$54.71
Cash per Share (MRQ)$21.84$3.64
Operating Cash Flow (TTM) i$1.53B$12.39B
Levered Free Cash Flow (TTM) i$304.62M$11.31B
Dividends
Last 12-Month Dividend Yield i6.87%8.67%
Last 12-Month Dividend i$8.86$18.40

Valuation & Enterprise Metrics Analysis: American Financial Group Inc. vs Progressive Corporation

MetricAFG (Apr 24, 2026)PGR (Apr 24, 2026)
Price Ratios
P/E Ratio (TTM) i12.9210.45
Forward P/E i10.8312.73
PEG Ratio i0.721.06
Price to Sales (TTM) i1.371.34
Price to Book (MRQ) i2.253.75
Market Capitalization
Market Capitalization i$11.01B$120.11B
Enterprise Value i$11.07B$126.25B
Enterprise Value Metrics
Enterprise to Revenue i1.391.41
Enterprise to EBITDA i8.708.33
Risk & Other Metrics
Beta i0.670.33
Book Value per Share (MRQ) i$57.78$54.71

Financial Statements Comparison: American Financial Group Inc. vs Progressive Corporation

Financial Metrics

Loading Financial Charts...

Revenue

Operating Margin

Profit Margin

Long Term Debt

Income Flow Analysis

Financial Statements Comparison

Income Statement

MetricAFG (2025)PGR (2025)
Revenue/Sales i8.12B87.64B
Cost of Goods Sold iN/AN/A
COGS % of Revenue i0.0%0.0%
Gross Profit iN/AN/A
Gross Margin i0.0%0.0%
Research & Development iN/AN/A
Operating Income (EBIT) iN/AN/A
Operating Margin i0.0%0.0%
EBITDA iN/AN/A
EBITDA Margin i0.0%0.0%
Pre-Tax Income i1.07B14.22B
Pre-Tax Income % of Revenue i13.2%16.2%
Income Tax i231.00M2.92B
Income Tax % of Revenue i2.8%3.3%
Net Income (Profit) i842.00M11.31B
Profit Margin i10.4%12.9%

Balance Sheet & Liquidity Metrics

MetricAFG (2025)PGR (2025)
Cash & Equivalents i1.73B125.00M
Total Current Assets iN/AN/A
Total Current Assets % of Revenue i0.0%0.0%
Total Current Liabilities iN/AN/A
Total Current Liabilities % of Revenue i0.0%0.0%
Long-Term Debt i1.82B6.90B
Long-Term Debt % of Revenue i22.4%7.9%
Total Shareholders Equity i4.82B30.32B
Retained Earnings i3.36B27.33B
Retained Earnings % of Revenue i41.4%31.2%
Property, Plant & Equipment iN/AN/A

Cash Flow Statement Comparison

MetricAFG (2025)PGR (2025)
Operating Cash Flow i393.00M12.39B
Operating Cash Flow % of Revenue i4.8%14.1%
Capital Expenditures iN/A-268.00M
Free Cash Flow i1.53B17.20B
FCF Margin i18.9%19.6%
Debt Repayment i0N/A
Common Stock Repurchase i-99.00M-166.00M

Short Interest & Institutional Ownership Analysis

MetricAFGPGR
Shares Short i1.53M7.29M
Short Ratio i2.712.32
Short % of Float i2.22%1.25%
Shares Outstanding i83.42M584.40M
Float Shares i71.86M582.21M
% Held by Insiders i20.39%0.25%
% Held by Institutions i68.37%89.29%
% Held by Public i11.24%10.46%

Dividend Analysis & Yield Comparison: American Financial Group Inc. vs Progressive Corporation

MetricAFGPGR
Last 12-Month Dividend i$8.86$18.40
Last 12-Month Dividend Yield i6.87%8.67%
3-Year Avg Annual Dividend i$7.52$6.62
3-Year Avg Dividend Yield i0.98%0.71%
3-Year Total Dividends i$22.56$19.85
Ex-Dividend DateFeb 13, 2026Jan 02, 2026